• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Joe’s Pizzeria

**OUR STORY**

Nestled in the heart of Lincoln, Illinois, Joe's Pizzeria channels the spirit of classic 1970s Chicago pizza joints. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, this beloved establishment is famed for its authentic Italian cuisine, offering everything from irresistible pizza to hearty spaghetti and meatballs. Customers rave about the quality ingredients and the unmistakable aroma of cooking that draws you in. Joe and his devoted staff pride themselves on providing exceptional service and a welcoming environment for families and friends. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, every visit promises a satisfying experience filled with genuine, home-cooked flavors.

Joe’s Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

Michael D.
Michael D.

Good pizza. Old time place. Reminds me of early 1970s Chicago pizza joints. Has that great pizza aroma.

Cathy B.
Cathy B.

Best pizza in Lincoln !!! Always order from Joe's!! Quality ingredients and perfect every time .

Ang H.
Ang H.

Last week we had Italian Beef sandwich & spaghetti with meatballs. The sandwich was the best!!!! I would get it again. Joe & his staff is kind & grateful for my business. Thanks Joe! See ya again soon.

Chekhouna T.
Chekhouna T.

Doesn't look like much when you walk past, but the smell of Italian cooking just draws you in. Joe's Pizzeria definitely has some of the best tasting pizza and spaghetti & meatballs. If you're ever in Lincoln Illinois be sure to stop by Joe's! Their authentic Italian cuisine will leave you full and happy.

Audrey C.
Audrey C.

Cash only - seating inside - but not a huge space - but pizza was good! Wish they had a patio space and/or a bigger menu - but love supporting local and this felt local :)

Mary L.
Mary L.

Although there are a lot of pizza places to get a pizza this place has become one of top picks. Love the crust, cheese, sauce and all. I will be coming back for more in the future. The dine in area is very run down, but this is no reflection of the food they serve. I will be doing carry out because I know they can do that! Give this place a try if you are feeling like a thin crust pizza. I've never been a big fan of thin crust, but this one I like.

Location

Welcome to Joe’s Pizzeria, a gem in Lincoln, IL, where nostalgia meets delightful Italian flavors. With a location that may appear unassuming from the outside, this pizzeria is a treasure trove of authentic tastes reminiscent of the classic Chicago pizza joints from the early '70s. The moment you step inside, the irresistible aroma of Italian cooking envelops you, drawing you into a warm embrace of culinary history.

Highlighting Joe's Offerings:

  • Quality Ingredients: Joe’s Pizzeria is renowned for its high-quality ingredients. Many patrons, such as Cathy B., rave that this is the "best pizza in Lincoln," consistently delivering perfection with each order.
  • Cozy Atmosphere: Though the space may be limited, Joe’s Pizzeria boasts a charming ambiance that enhances your dining experience. With outdoor seating available, it’s perfect for families, groups, and casual gatherings over a slice of pizza.
  • Versatile Menu: From mouthwatering pizza to hearty Italian beef sandwiches and comforting spaghetti with meatballs, there is something for everyone. Regulars like Ang H. appreciate the variety, noting that the Italian beef sandwich is a must-try!
  • Welcoming Service: Joe and his staff are celebrated for their friendly service, making every patron feel valued and appreciated. A frequent visitor, Ang H., shares their gratitude for the staff's kindness and attentiveness—an essential quality in any dining experience.
  • Local Favorite: In a town like Lincoln, supporting local businesses holds immense value. The charm of Joe’s Pizzeria lies not just in its food but also in its role as a community staple. Despite its cash-only policy and limited seating, it continues to attract both locals and visitors looking for a true taste of Italy.

Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pizza, a comforting pasta dish, or simply want to soak up the vibrant Italian atmosphere, Joe’s Pizzeria is the place to be. Don’t let its modest exterior fool you; inside awaits a feast of flavors that will leave you both satisfied and eager for more. The next time you’re in Lincoln, make sure to stop by—your taste buds will thank you!

For reservations or takeout, give them a call at (217) 732-3553. Enjoy authentic Italian cuisine at Joe’s Pizzeria, where every bite is a delightful journey through tradition and taste!